thoughts from a basset hound-loving writer who supposedly destroyed civilization by marrying his partner
Tuesday, December 29, 2009
Nastiness in the Illinois Senate Race
Here's an excerpt from an interesting story from the Chicago Tribune. The front runner cited is Representative Mark Kirk (left).
The article continues by noting that Kirk's campaign manager said that the ad "is degrading to the political process. The people of Illinois deserve better."
True enough. But the Republican Party doesn't really make it clear what's degrading about it. Being called gay? Or using gay as an insult? All too often these sorts of accusations -- if one can be "accused" of being gay -- are met with proclamations of disgust and vehement denials. Another article in the Tribune notes Martin's history of bizarre attacks, including an accusation that George Bush was a cocaine addict. But the unspoken message is that being gay is the same as having an addictive illness. Or that being gay is "as bad" as falsely labeling someone as gay. Of course it isn't. And it will be a good day when someone notes this when denying rumors and false statements. It will be a better day when we don't have to note this, when calling some gay will be seen as ridiculous as calling someone Catholic or female or -- fill in the blank.
SPRINGFIELD, Ill. - Top Illinois Republicans condemned a perennial candidate's decision Monday to air a political ad questioning the sexual orientation of the party's front-runner in the US Senate race.
The Republican Party said it would no longer consider Andy Martin (right) a legitimate candidate.
"His statements today are consistent with his history of bizarre behavior and often times hate-filled speech which has no place in the Illinois Republican Party," said party chairman Pat Brady.
Fellow Senate candidate Patrick Hughes said the radio ad has no place in the campaign. Dan Proft, a GOP candidate for governor, called it repugnant.
The article continues by noting that Kirk's campaign manager said that the ad "is degrading to the political process. The people of Illinois deserve better."
True enough. But the Republican Party doesn't really make it clear what's degrading about it. Being called gay? Or using gay as an insult? All too often these sorts of accusations -- if one can be "accused" of being gay -- are met with proclamations of disgust and vehement denials. Another article in the Tribune notes Martin's history of bizarre attacks, including an accusation that George Bush was a cocaine addict. But the unspoken message is that being gay is the same as having an addictive illness. Or that being gay is "as bad" as falsely labeling someone as gay. Of course it isn't. And it will be a good day when someone notes this when denying rumors and false statements. It will be a better day when we don't have to note this, when calling some gay will be seen as ridiculous as calling someone Catholic or female or -- fill in the blank.
Oh, Canada
Well, after a surprisingly long 14 hour drive we are in our home away from home, Toronto. The wait at the border was 3 1/2 hours. We forgot that this was the last day of a long weekend for Canadians, who celebrate Boxing Day. Couple that with a few snow storms on the way (including a lake effect storm in Buffalo) and possibly increased vigilance after the latest terrorist attempt and our trip was 4-5 hours longer than usual.
Of course, so much time in the car allowed me time to think. And one thing I thought about was how our marriage status changed as we traveled from Boston to Toronto. It's pretty crazy.
1. In Massachusetts we were in a state that allows same-sex couples to get married and that acknowledges same-sex marriages from outside the state. Pretty straight forward, no pun intended.

2. In New York we were in a state that doesn't allow same-sex marriage but does recognize same-sex marriages from other states, including ours. A little more complicated.
3. In Canada we are in a country that allows same-sex marriage but doesn't recognize our marriage because foreign governments generally only recognize agreements that are recognized but the federal government of the United States. And since the Defense of Marriage Act prohibits the U.S. federal government from recognizing a same-sex marriage from Massachusetts, Canada can't recognize our marriage. (Usually, however, in practice they do. When we enter Canada by air, we are usually allowed to fill out one customs card as "family," although this is at the whim of the customs agent. Compare this to the US customs agent who, once we told him we were married in Massachusetts, sternly admonished us and sent Bruce back to the line so he could process us separately -- even though we had filled out separate cards. File this under "ever wonder why we call it hate?")
More tomorrow. It's 2:00 AM (we arrived at 1:30 AM) and are winding down, along with our bassets, Shakespeare and Willa, who are just as happy to be sleeping on the sofa as Bruce and I are to have finally reached our destination.
Of course, so much time in the car allowed me time to think. And one thing I thought about was how our marriage status changed as we traveled from Boston to Toronto. It's pretty crazy.
1. In Massachusetts we were in a state that allows same-sex couples to get married and that acknowledges same-sex marriages from outside the state. Pretty straight forward, no pun intended.
2. In New York we were in a state that doesn't allow same-sex marriage but does recognize same-sex marriages from other states, including ours. A little more complicated.
3. In Canada we are in a country that allows same-sex marriage but doesn't recognize our marriage because foreign governments generally only recognize agreements that are recognized but the federal government of the United States. And since the Defense of Marriage Act prohibits the U.S. federal government from recognizing a same-sex marriage from Massachusetts, Canada can't recognize our marriage. (Usually, however, in practice they do. When we enter Canada by air, we are usually allowed to fill out one customs card as "family," although this is at the whim of the customs agent. Compare this to the US customs agent who, once we told him we were married in Massachusetts, sternly admonished us and sent Bruce back to the line so he could process us separately -- even though we had filled out separate cards. File this under "ever wonder why we call it hate?")More tomorrow. It's 2:00 AM (we arrived at 1:30 AM) and are winding down, along with our bassets, Shakespeare and Willa, who are just as happy to be sleeping on the sofa as Bruce and I are to have finally reached our destination.
Labels:
Canada,
Massachusetts,
New York,
same-sex marriage
Monday, December 28, 2009
Free speech issues in Washington, DC
There's a free speech debate happening in Washington, DC right now, and some LGBT groups find that they aren't in agreement about what to do. At issue is a media campaign orchestrated by anti-marriage equality groups. As part of this campaign, they have bought space on public buses that urge a vote on gay marriage. (Here's my own two cents here: I know there are pro-equality people who support referenda, but I think they are rare. The "let the people vote" campaign -- which we saw in Massachusetts a number of years ago -- is really let the people vote to oppose same-sex marriage.) Full Equality Now has requested the advertisements be taken down, citing that because of their location "they cannot be avoided... countless LGBT citizens are forced to stare down discrimination as they board the bus to go somewhere or are even passed by an advertisement on the street." Other activists like Mitch Wood, president of the Gay and Lesbian Activists Alliance, believe allowing the ads supports freedom of expression. The alliance's statement in opposition to taking down the ads refers to a moment in history when LGBT advocates used buses to advertise:
As supporters of civil marriage equality, we also embrace the principle of free speech enshrined in the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which makes our own advocacy possible. Indeed, the then-named Gay Activists Alliance thirty years ago won a court battle against WMATA for the right to place educational posters in Metrobuses with the message, 'Someone In Your Life Is Gay.' WMATA is a quasi-governmental body and is thus subject to the First Amendment. We, the undersigned, therefore urge you to reject the misguided censorship advocated by Full Equality Now DC.It's a tough question. I'll keep you posted.
Sunday, December 27, 2009
Five more stories of 2009
Here are the second five LGBT stories of 2009. Again, they are in no particular order:
6. The Ugandan government considers a bill that would make homosexuality punishable by death. Top notch reporting by folks like Rachel Maddow brought this story to the attention of millions. Not only was the Ugandan government condemned -- and it looks like this condemnation worked to stop the death penalty of LGBT people -- the relationship between the Ugandan government and prominent religious and political figures were also uncovered.

7. Losses in Maine and in New York. Heartbreaking? Of course. But the loses highlighted two of the most moving moments this year: Ruth Hassell-Thompson's (right) stunning speech in the New York State Senate and the testimony of Phillip Spooner, the WWII vet who spoke out against the referendum in Maine.
8. President Obama signs a hate crimes bill that includes LGBT people. To have the government even acknowledge LGBT people without condemnation was unique after eight years of George Bush.
9. The war expands in Afghanistan. Yes, this story affected everyone deeply. But the increase in troops in Afghanistan -- no matter what your feelings about the escalation -- highlighted once more the absurdity of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell." As more and more of our troops are sent to this war, fewer and fewer are available for anything else. In this light, is it logical to deny thousands and thousands of capable people the right to serve? And remember: the first George Bush temporarily suspended the prohibition of LGBT people in the military during the first Gulf War. Almost 20 years later, repealing that ban permanently is still being debated.

10. Intolerance grows in the right wing media. I know. This may seem impossible. But the right wing media -- Limbaugh, Beck and Hannity (left) to name a few -- has led the charge to rid the Republican party of anyone who speaks with a modicum of moderation. It is leading a purity movement that will either destroy the party or profoundly change our country. From calling President Obama "a racist" to attacking Kevin Jennings for being gay, the right wing media has become more radical and hyperbolic.
6. The Ugandan government considers a bill that would make homosexuality punishable by death. Top notch reporting by folks like Rachel Maddow brought this story to the attention of millions. Not only was the Ugandan government condemned -- and it looks like this condemnation worked to stop the death penalty of LGBT people -- the relationship between the Ugandan government and prominent religious and political figures were also uncovered.
7. Losses in Maine and in New York. Heartbreaking? Of course. But the loses highlighted two of the most moving moments this year: Ruth Hassell-Thompson's (right) stunning speech in the New York State Senate and the testimony of Phillip Spooner, the WWII vet who spoke out against the referendum in Maine.
8. President Obama signs a hate crimes bill that includes LGBT people. To have the government even acknowledge LGBT people without condemnation was unique after eight years of George Bush.
9. The war expands in Afghanistan. Yes, this story affected everyone deeply. But the increase in troops in Afghanistan -- no matter what your feelings about the escalation -- highlighted once more the absurdity of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell." As more and more of our troops are sent to this war, fewer and fewer are available for anything else. In this light, is it logical to deny thousands and thousands of capable people the right to serve? And remember: the first George Bush temporarily suspended the prohibition of LGBT people in the military during the first Gulf War. Almost 20 years later, repealing that ban permanently is still being debated.
10. Intolerance grows in the right wing media. I know. This may seem impossible. But the right wing media -- Limbaugh, Beck and Hannity (left) to name a few -- has led the charge to rid the Republican party of anyone who speaks with a modicum of moderation. It is leading a purity movement that will either destroy the party or profoundly change our country. From calling President Obama "a racist" to attacking Kevin Jennings for being gay, the right wing media has become more radical and hyperbolic.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



